OpRisk & Compliance - Magazine on operational risk, corporate governance, business continuity, compliance, financial crime
OpRisk & Compliance - Free trial
OpRisk & Compliance - Magazine on operational risk, compliance About Oprisk & Compliance Subscribe to OpRisk & Compliance Advertise on OpRisk & Compliance Contacts at OpRisk & Compliance Free trial to OpRisk & Compliance Help on OpRisk & Compliance
Career Center Jobs and Career Management in the Financial Markets, Banking & Finance Career Center
  Job Seekers Sign in / Register Recruiter's Sign-in
ADVICE
 
Guest comment: Migration and the points based system
18 Jun 2008
The success of the UK, and the City of London’s financial services sector, has been built on our country’s tradition of openness – not only to international capital, but also to the immigration of the best and the brightest from around the world. A full 30% of jobs in London are filled by people born outside the UK, including a quarter of senior managers in financial and business services.

I firmly believe that immigration has clear benefits for the UK labour market and the economy as a whole. By bringing in innovative ideas, core business skills and other valuable talents, migrants play a key role in contributing to the prosperity and productivity of the UK and complementing our domestic workforce. In the same way that free trade and capital mobility boosts our income, so too does immigration. A wider labour market increases flexibility, and matches individuals with different skill sets to job opportunities more effectively.

Tier One

Earlier this year, the Government launched the first phase of the new Points Based System (PBS) for immigration. The Points Based System will enable us to manage migration more effectively, while creating a fairer and more transparent system that identifies the skilled workers the economy needs.

Tier One of the PBS was launched in February 2008. This builds upon the success of the UK’s Highly Skilled Migrant Programme, by continuing to attract those possessing the top-class skills the UK needs to remain a global leader in the fields of international finance, business and technological innovation.

Tier One will cover individuals from outside the European Economic Area (EEA) seeking highly skilled jobs in the UK– in sectors ranging from accounting, consultancy, investment banking and insurance to private equity.

Tier One also warmly welcomes entrepreneurs who want to invest in the UK by setting up a business, or investors who want to make a substantial financial investment in the UK.

Just as with the previous system, those applying to work in the UK on Tier One will be required to prove that they can speak English and are able to support themselves.

However, individuals who can show they have enough points to qualify for Tier One will not require a job offer to apply. Points will be awarded on the basis of the individual’s skills, experience, age and past earnings.

This will ensure that we continue to boost the UK’s economy by attracting and retaining the brightest and the best, furthering the success of London as an international financial centre as well as the success of regionally important business and finance centres such as Edinburgh, Glasgow, Leeds, Manchester, Birmingham and Bristol.

Tier Two

The Government also recently unveiled its intentions for Tier Two of the PBS, which is for skilled migrants and is aimed at enabling UK employers to recruit individuals from outside the EEA to fill a particular skilled job that cannot be filled by a British or European worker.

In Tier Two, employers will be able to sponsor skilled migrants to work in the UK when a particular shortage occupation has been identified, or when a business has been unable to fill a post from within the EEA.

As with the other tiers, an applicant wanting to come to the UK under this tier will need to show that he or she has enough points to qualify, and these points will be awarded according to objective and transparent criteria.

Individuals coming here through the Tier Two system for inter-company transfers have three years to learn basic English.

Put together, the Government is confident that Tier One and Tier Two of the new system will mean that both domestic and international employers based in the UK will be able to meet skills gaps quickly by attracting the right people into the labour market.

The Points Based System will lead to greater predictability to meet the needs of UK-based employers, as well as the aspirations of graduates and experienced hires from around the world to work in the UK.

It is vital now, more than ever, that the Government maintains London's competitive position in global financial markets by attracting and retaining highly skilled migrants – and I sincerely encourage readers of e-FinancialCareers to strongly consider starting and furthering the pursuit of their careers in the UK.

Further details of the Points Based System can be found online at www.ukba.homeoffice.gov.uk

Kitty Ussher is MP for Burnley and Economic Secretary to the Treasury, with responsibility for matters involving banking and finance.

Related Articles:
Guest comment: The City must not drive away its skilled staff
Not much hope for French bankers in France, either
London bankers are kings of the castle
Related Links:
Guardian: British people don't want to work
The Times: Darling tries to seduce the City
Financial Times: Ussher soothes City on migrant talent
Reader Comments
Date: 18 Jun 2008
Name/Email: Wizard of EC1 ()
Company:
Kitty - an avalanche of words that say nothing, little doubt that you were a civil servant before inheriting a safe seat. Migrants do little other than put downwards pressure on compensation, thought this would be apparent by now. The issue facing the City at the moment is skills fade and an inefficient deployment of the existing talent pool. There are tens of thousands out of work, with little chance of finding employment in FS in the medium term. It is NOT vital now to attract new highly skilled migrants – it IS vital to get the tens of thousands of highly experienced and highly skilled financial services staff back into full time work. I am genuinely concerned that you do not see this, in writing this article you have shown a naivety and that you don’t know what’s happening in the Banking market at present. An own goal.

Date: 18 Jun 2008
Name/Email: asrobertson ()
Company:
Load of rubbish.Client of mine on highly skilled migrant visa is a Pilates instructor. What benefit is that to the economy? So Labour MPs can get pampered when they're having their 20 weeks holiday per year?

Date: 18 Jun 2008
Name/Email: alhamduabdul ()
Company:
Is it fair that NOMURA does not accept applications for a certain position from candidates who are on valid workpermits that require renewals?I am a migrant worker with 5years work experience in the banking sector and have noticed that a candidates status is irrelivant in the sence that if he/she decides to move on,theres not much that can be done. There are situations whereby British and EU nationals have filled positions at my work place but have left after 2 or 3months.

Date: 18 Jun 2008
Name/Email: Job Less ()
Company:
Not great timing of this article considering the industry wide job cuts... then thats the Government for you - completely out of touch with reality

Date: 18 Jun 2008
Name/Email: Wizard of EC1 ()
Company:
Job Less, Kitty was a career civil servant, then parachuted into a safe seat. She can have no understanding of the problems of the 50,000 made redundant recently - probably not even aware. What a bizarre article to post on this site?

Date: 18 Jun 2008
Name/Email: Job Less ()
Company:
Attract? Retain? how exactly? I cant see the attraction of furthering a career in the country with the highest tax burden and cost of living in Europe - ably led by a bunch of clowns who's only option in tough economic times is to up taxation... Oh and if you're lucky they'll probably loose the personal information in your application form at some point

Date: 18 Jun 2008
Name/Email: alan ()
Company:
wizard hits it on the head. i have seen migrants coming in to the City prepared to work for peanuts. Invariably there is a wife in tow who is also working for peanuts somewhere else in the City and a hired migrant nanny who is also working for peanuts. They find it easy to get by because they have been used to low living standards back in their home countries. Therefore a 2 bed flat in Tottenham Hale is a luxury. This guy was so happy with his crap salary that when it came to annual pay rises/bonuses, we all suffered as a result.

Date: 18 Jun 2008
Name/Email: Dotun ()
Company:
I don't understand these ludicrous comments about immigrants. It's fine when banks mess up their balance sheets and then run straight to Sovereign Wealth Funds for salvation but it's inappropriate to bring in immigrants. RIDICULOUS! So it's a case of we want your money and not your people.:lol:))

Date: 18 Jun 2008
Name/Email: Migrant ()
Company:
Skilled migrants such as I pay British taxes, tend not to use the NHS (we go to our home countries for cheap and very good private medical care) and we pay for Brits on the dole. We also have limited access to other social services. In my mind this all points to being a net contributor. Moreover since we tend to work hard, I believe efficiency has improved in a number of sectors. As long as your kids spurn mathematics and science in favour of "media studies" and other similarly meaningless subjects at school, you will have to rely on migrants to keep a number of things functioning properly.

Date: 18 Jun 2008
Name/Email: DominiConnor ()
Company:
The system is OK, but has major bugs in it. It gives equal weight to a degree in media studies as one in physics or IT. Most MBA get direct admission, but no industry qualifications are given any weight at all. The real situation is not the Daily Mail style "foreigners working for peaqnuts", but a serious shortage of good quality graduates at home. Look at the "success" of fake degrees like Media Studies, or the way you can get a degree for merely learning a foreign language. In many countries, that's seen as something like learning to drive, not a major accomplishment.,

Date: 18 Jun 2008
Name/Email: Foreigner ()
Company:
Wizard is right winged jerk. I agree totally with Migrant above, as long as your children stick to studying media studies and stab each other on the streets of Peckham and Brixton, hard-working, intellectual immigrants like myself will be the ones you fall on to do the highly quantitative and mentally demanding jobs in the City. I have worked for UBS, Credit Suisse, GS and currently ABN AMRO/RBS and have had the pleasure of working with English as well as migrants from places like US, other EU, Switzerland, India, Ghana, South Africa etc. Most people from outside the UK tend to have a stronger work ethic than their UK counterparts. This is not always the case though. Plus we immigrants cannot claim job-seekers allowance and other State benefits when redundancies happen although we pay taxes and NI. Most decent migrants like myself are very grateful for working in the UK and appreciate the opportunities presented to us. In my view the British are the most pleasant people in the world, especially to foreigners.

Date: 18 Jun 2008
Name/Email: Ravshonbek ()
Company:
I think migrant workers have to be thankful for the opportunities and chances given by this country. You might not be able to find this kind of openness anywhere else. Fair enough, you pay higher taxes as you are earning enough to pay that much tax! You are living in a country where the technology and the skills make people's life easy. You pay the tax to finance the technology upgrade and pay for the skills. If you do not pay that much tax you would not get this much better life, would you??? I am a migrant as well brother.

Date: 18 Jun 2008
Name/Email: Ed ()
Company:
I like my cheap polish plumbing and philipino nanny. Let them stay!

Date: 19 Jun 2008
Name/Email: Asian Brit ()
Company:
I am British working in a Middle Eastern country and have realised we Brits don't protect our own. Job priority should be given to Brits and then to immigrants, similalry training and benfits should be more than the immigrants.....I probably sound racist, you'll be shocked to hear that im a second generation British Asian....the country to which I was born into (and the one I call home and love dearly) is going to the pits!!!!

Date: 19 Jun 2008
Name/Email: Wizard of EC1 ()
Company:
Foreigner - hard day at ABN, a little touchy? (I guess every day at ABN is fraught these days). My point was - to explain in simple terms, that with 50,000+ redundancies of highly skilled and experienced staff, do we really need to add more, less experienced people to the pool? Why throw petrol on a fire? Ms Ussher's role is to ensure efficiency in the FS job market, I suggest she has demonstrated a limited grasp of the current issues. INow … I suggest you get back to work, lest your RBS masters put you on their “List” and you find out how truly bad the FS employment market is. More conservative than right wing, I would never support a workers party – left or right wing.

Date: 19 Jun 2008
Name/Email: Hedgie ()
Company:
For far too long the inv. banks have been filled with talentless snake oil salesmen living off their old boy networks. As we all know inv. banks make most of their money by ripping off clients (mainly the general public though insurance and pension funds) and it appears that the vast majority of redundant City workers will struggle to get 25% of their old salaries in the real world (before posting responses about free markets etc compare IPO fees in the US to the UK)… Time to change the old guard, easy come easy go…

Date: 19 Jun 2008
Name/Email: Russian in the City ()
Company:
What I think some people are missing is that UK immigration system creates jobs. I work in an American investment bank and focus solely on Emerging Markets (Russia, Kazakhstan, Ukraine). My job can be based anywhere - Moscow, Dubai or Amsterdam. It is currently in London because (i) international companies do not have problems with getting work permits for highly paid people and (ii) London has historically been an emerging markets trading center. There are 20 or 30 people in Operations and Finance, supporting our desk. They are primarily UK citizens and get paid well above average. If I am not able to work in London, I do not think my role can be filled in by highly qualified British people from other parts of investment banks. Russian clients prefer to deal with Russian native speakers. So... if I cannot do my job out of London, I will probably move to Moscow or Dubai and 20-30 support jobs are very like to follow the front office move. London has only become the financial center for growing emerging markets and Islamic Finance businesses because immigration laws for qualified people are relatively flexible. If this changes, UK financial sector will lose in the long run.

Date: 01 Jul 2008
Name/Email: Taylor ()
Company:
What a bunch of xenophobes. You should be ashamed of yourselves.

Email this article Return to advice index
Print article
Search Archive
See all articles 
 
Send us your comments or article ideas

 


Poll
The likelihood of writedowns spreading to corporate debt is:
Very, very low: 4.9%
Lowish: 26.2%
I don't know: 18.6%
Very high: 32.4%
Very, very high: 17.8%
More to say?

ALSO IN THIS SECTION:

MORE NEWS & ADVICE:
JOB MARKET NEWS
PAY NEWS
GRADUATE / MBA NEWS
SALARY SURVEYS
ASK THE EXPERT
SECTORS EXPLAINED
ADVICE
A DAY IN THE LIFE
EMPLOYER PROFILES
© Incisive Media Ltd. 2007 Jobs at Incisive Media | Terms and conditions | Privacy policy | Accessibility statement